Skip to main content
Clean Hydrogen Partnership

CGH2 cylinders truck collision

Event

Event ID
954
Quality
Description

The incident occurred during delivery of a bundle of 28 cylinders to a metal manufacturing company. A hydrogen leak occurred due to due to a wrong operation of the the truck crane. While loading an empty bundle, the piping of a full cylinder was hit, casuing the leak.
Since the release could not be stopped by intervening at the leaking point, the fire brigade decided to vent the whole content of the pallet (246 m3) by gradually opening the valves and by keeping the rack cool.

The rack of the bottles was empty after four hours and the rescue operation ends at noon after the cylinder rack has been checked by an expert from the gas supply company. The residents returned to their homes and the plant's activity restarted one hour later.

Event Initiating system
Classification of the physical effects
Unignited Hydrogen Release
Nature of the consequences
leak no ignition
Macro-region
Europe
Country
France
Date
Component involved
piping (collector)
Failure mode
rupture, no ignition
Initiating cause
impact, rollover, crash
Root CAUSE analysis

The INITIATING cause was the mechanical damage of one of the compressed hydrogen cylinders, by an erroneous manoeuvring of the operator .

The ROOT CAUSE had two components a manoeuvre error and an inadequate safety design of the load. it should be possible to isolate the individual cylinders of the pallet before shipping, to minimise the hazard related to a leak on one of them.

Root causes
Date entry in HIAD
01/01/2018

Facility

Application
Hydrogen transport and distribution
Sub-application
CGH2 cylinders truck
Hydrogen supply chain stage
All components affected

cylinders

Process temperature range [C]
ambient temperature (-50°C to +50°C)
Process pressure range [MPa]
medium to high pressure (10 to 50 MPa)
Location type
Open
Location
industrial area
Operational condition
Pre-event occurrences

The accident took place when replacing the empty cylinders with full ones.

Emergency & Consequences

Number of fatalities
0
Number of injured persons
0
Post-event summary

No consequence.

Emergency action

Since the leak could not be stopped locally, The fire brigade decided to drain the whole content of the pallet (246 m3) by gradually opening the valves and by keeping the rack cool.

The rack of the bottles was empty after four hours and the rescue operation ends at noon after the cylinder rack has been checked by an expert from the gas supply company. The residents returned to their homes and the plant's activity restarted one hour later.

Emergency evaluation

A specialized expert emergency support cell estimated the leakage rate at 0.48 kg/s. They also estimated the distance to the Low flammability limit (LFL) about 30 m and the effects of an explosion in the event of delayed ignition of the cloud in the open air at 50 and 20 mbar over-pressure, for respectively 80 and 130 m.

Lesson Learnt

Lesson Learnt

The ARIA report (see references) does not mention any corrective action following the incident, but improved (safer) loading/unloading procedure would certainly be required.

In-depth data

Release type
gas
Involved substances (% vol)
H2 100%
Released amount (kg)
21
Release temperature [°C]
25
Release pressure [MPa]
20
Probable IGNITION SOURCE

References

Sources categories
ARIA
Reference & weblink

Event description in the French database ARIA
https://www.aria.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/accident/35405/
(accessed October 2020)